Tuesday, July 19, 2016

Blackwolf Run - River

Rankings

Golf Digest:  #91
Golfweek:  #73 Modern

A college-roommate reunion led me to Kohler, WI in late summer of '15.  As a golf destination, Kohler was a great venue for our eight-man trip.  We stayed at the Inn on Woodlake since The American Club (the ritzier venue) was sold out.  The Inn was quaint - kind of a woodsy Residence Inn.  We played three rounds in two days and then headed off to Erin Hills.  Since I'm penning this a year after my trip, it'll be lighter on details and heavier on my big-picture takeaways.

Whistling Straits is a links venue, while Blackwolf Run winds through woods, a river, lakes, etc.  It is apples to oranges, but equally as impressive.  The Blackwolf pro shop is understated and doesn't feel like a big resort.  Perhaps our week was less crowded than others, but we did not feel like we were a bunch of sheep being herded through the turnstiles (Whistling felt a bit like this gearing up to tee of on #1).  

Blackwolf has 36 holes, the River and the Meadow.  We played the River course, but had to skip the Meadow for scheduling reasons.  After deciding to play the tips, we quickly found that driving it straight is more important at Blackwolf than at Whistling.  While both courses give you trouble if you're off the beaten path, a wayward drive on the River course can be in such dense trees that you can't attempt to find it.  Hence, my score reflected the countless Pro V1s I donated.  

The River was in amazing condition, and the greens were quick.  We took carts, which is not preferable on top golf courses, but there are a number of long drives in between holes that necessitate a cart.  The River's holes didn't feel redundant, and at 7,400 yards from the tips, there wasn't an opportunity to leave the driver in the bag to focus on hitting fairways.  Second shots were brutal on many holes, even with great drives.  

The course offers some tee shots that are not intuitive, and with caddies that are unfamiliar with your game, it can lead to confusion when picking your lines.  Playing the course a second time would be optimal to feel comfortable over the ball.  Even some lay-up shots can be a little confusing playing blind.  However, the course is not unfair.  It is simply a demanding layout and having any uncertainty over the ball can lead to disaster.  

I'm a fan of lush, parkland style courses, and Blackwolf did not disappoint.  I'd definitely take another trip to Kohler to play this one, especially with so many great courses nearby.   

The Valley Club of Montecito

Rankings

Golf Digest:  #80
Golfweek:  #38 Classic

The Valley Club clubhouse sits on a hillside overlooking the Pacific Ocean near Santa Barbara, CA.  I played the course a couple times in U.S. Mid-Amateur qualifiers.  The first time I birdied the last three holes to shoot even and missed qualifying by a shot or two when the last group on the course had two guys break 70.  Tough luck.  

Despite my near miss, the course is incredible.  There are two distinct sides to VC.  The 1st, 15th, 16th, 17th, and 18th are on one side of the street situated in a meadow-like area.  The other side of the course winds through trees and runs along a creek.  Both sides are a great experience, although I enjoy the meadow holes more.  The clubhouse is old-school with lockers that seem to be a throwback to a simpler time.  They don't feel dated, they feel vintage.  Is that the same thing?  

Regardless, the Alister MacKenzie design is pure.  The greens complexes have a lot going on and I enjoy the mounding and closely shaved areas where you need to decide to putt or chip.  And boy are they fast.  This is definitely a must-play if you can pull off an invite.  I could play it daily and not tire of the layout.  

Bandon Trails

Rankings

Golf Digest:  #70
Golfweek:  #19 Modern

My trip to Bandon was such a whirlwind, these reviews will be short.  I pulled off a late night flight from a conference in Vegas into Eugene - drove the 2.5 hours to Bandon in the pitch black - and rolled in at ~3am.  First tee time at 9am...welcome to Bandon!

Trails was the third course I played, and the most traditional.  It feels as you'd expect of a Coore/Crenshaw design.  I may have enjoyed Trails the most - it was picturesque even though it sits a bit inland.  Elevation changes and doglegs kept things interesting, and the wind was no joke - as you'd assume at Bandon.  A caddie was critical for a first timer, and from what I understand most of them are solid at the resort.  However, we had the same caddies the entire time, and they were a lot of fun.  A lot of them are great players as well.  

I spent three days at Bandon, and would have liked to have spent one more day.  But, you take the invite when it comes.  It's a special place for golfers - it's just golf, nothing else.  I love it.


Dallas National

Rankings

Golf Digest:  #61
Golfweek:  #41 Modern

How I got on:  I had the head pro from my home club call and set me and a friend up for a round.  DNGC does not allow unaccompanied guests, so we needed to play with their assistant pro.  That proved helpful since we didn't know our way around.  

It was crazy hot and I have a hard time remembering the course because I was spent after the round.  I do remember it being fairly typical Fazio with more elevation change than is typical for Dallas.  Conditioning was superb, and is a must play if you get the chance.  I'll have to take another whirl at this one when I'm not suffering from heat stroke!

Old Macdonald

Rankings

Golf Digest:  #55
Golfweek:  #5 Modern

I showed up at Bandon after having been told by many folks that Old Macdonald was their least favorite course of the four.  Perhaps it was my low expectations - who knows - but I really enjoyed Old Mac.  It was unique and offered some fun shots requiring creativity.  Other than the blind shot over a hill on #16, it's all right in front of you other than all the elephants buried in the greens.  The course is wide open and you can generally hit it anywhere, but I was able to find some gorse when I was WAY offline (it happens too frequently).  With no real protection from the elements, the wind really whips across Old Mac.  That also helped demand varying shots into the wild green complexes.  I found myself numerous times waffling between various shot options, and that was the fun of it.  

I'm not sure I have a ranking of the Bandon courses.  I think I need to have another go at them.  No favorites yet, they're all great.

Scioto CC

Rankings

Golf Digest:  #50
Golfweek:  #56 Classic

How I got on:  A good friend's stepfather set us up with a foursome during a golf trip that also included a round at Muirfield Village.  I'm not sure how our round was arranged, but our caddie didn't seem to be too excited to forecaddie for four guests.  

The course layout was challenging and would have played LONG from the tips, but our caddie wouldn't have any of that despite my friend and I shooting in the 70s from the tees we played (I don't recall which ones, but they were something of a hybrid between white and blue).  The course has a modest amount of trees, but not dense enough to prevent you from seeing a lot of the course from most holes.  The greens were very quick and in great shape.  It was obvious the course would be a perfect "play every day" track.  

Spyglass Hill

Rankings

Golf Digest:  #48
Golfweek:  #24 Modern

Review to come

Bethpage - Black

Rankings

Golf Digest:  #43
Golfweek:  #22 Classic

Review to come

Erin Hills

Rankings

Golf Digest:  #42
Golfweek:  #127 Modern

Erin Hills was played after our 54 holes at Whistling Straits.  I could have been wearing clouds on my feet and they'd have been sore after that much walking.  So another 10 miles of walking was going to be great for my dogs.  And boy is Erin Hills a trek.  The caddies should've been sherpas.  

I thought Erin Hills would be my least favorite course of the golf trip, but it was actually my favorite.  The scale of it, the uniqueness of holes, the wildflowers and rolling terrain - it was a perfect setting.  It may sound nerdy, but the clouds were like a postcard and the perfect background for some good golf photos.  

The short par 3 9th hole was an epic experience.  Only a lob wedge away, but our foursome of single-digit handicappers were a combined 9 over.  Some spots are just not to be found on that hole.  

The long par 4 10th was a BEAST!  We all hit great drives, but from the tips into a nasty wind it was at least a par 5.  I bombed a hybrid and barely eeked my way onto the green.  A fantastic hole that presented a great challenge.  

The only downside is that the course is in the middle of nowhere.  While there are cabins on site, they were full when we booked.  It's fine, but just a little obstacle to be aware of.  The U.S. Open this year would have gotten better reviews if the leaderboard was packed with household names.  I believe the runaway by Koepka made some look at the course with the same "eh" that the closing holes of the Open provided.  It's too bad.  I loved it even though it is new and has no golf pedigree. 




Garden City GC

Rankings

Golf Digest:  #49
Golfweek:  #28 Classic

A trip to New York was supposed to include a visit to Deepdale Golf Club, but my friend that planned to host had qualified for the U.S. Open Sectionals the same week and thus was tied up trying to leave his mark on history.  So it appeared no golf was in the cards.  However, one of the other members of our intended foursome called in a favor and we were back on...at Garden City Golf Club.  Talk about a fortunate turn of events!  

Much has been written about the history of Garden City, which was established in 1899.  I don't intend to, nor do I have the credentials to, walk through the lengthy happenings at GCGC.  The club has hosted a U.S. Open, multiple U.S. Amateurs, and a Walker Cup.  Arriving at the property and walking through the doors wearing a jacket (as required) feels like turning the calendar back by 100 years.  You'd never know it was 2016.  The front desk is to your left as you walk in, and the gentleman manning it is more than happy to point you in the right direction.  To the right is the locker room through a swinging saloon-style half door.  The dark green room has a giant moose head on the wall, and lockers that are boxy, wooden, and have a bit of metal grating on the front.  They probably haven't been touched in decades other than minor repairs.  Jackets hang on numerous coat racks as members shed them prior to heading out to the course.  On the opposite side of the clubhouse, behind the front desk, is the bar and then the grill.  The bar appears just as old as the rest of the edifice, as does the grill.  I felt like Walter Travis himself could walk in and it wouldn't be surprising.  

On to the course.  The terrain is essentially flat with fairways winding through tall grasses that often present crappy lies in addition to the hosel-grabbing fescue.  I found myself in the weeds many times, and often the recovery was not pretty.  In my defense, we played in a 2-3 club wind all day, which is abnormal at GC.  It was fun nonetheless, even though the course record was not in anyone's cross hairs.  

Again, a hole-by-hole walk through has been done before, so my focus will be on what stood out to me.     

The range is small, short, and looks more like hitting balls onto The Sandlot, but it doesn't detract from the experience.  Right outside the pro shop is the first tee, a driveable par 4.  As with most of the course, water does not come in play.  But...there are plenty of natural, unlandscaped areas that include ditches, fescue, and other places you don't want to find yourself.  Such is the area around the first green that awaits your wayward drive or approach.  

Garden City's simplicity is its beauty.  Creative bunkering, green complexes, and contouring are more utilized than trees, lakes, or creeks.  It's a walking course that I'd love another chance at to appreciate the subtleties.  

The 18th is a mid-length par 3 over a lake toward the clubhouse.  It's a bit daunting because there can often be a crowd eating on the patio and watching your every move.  I didn't break any windows and secured an up-and-down par, so I didn't embarrass myself or my host.

Garden City and many classic courses of the same era do not wow you with an opulent clubhouses or tricked-up golf holes.  It is a window in to golf from 100 years ago, which has a distinct feel and reverence.  

Baltusrol GC - Lower

Rankings

Golf Digest:  #41
Golfweek:  #45 Classic

How I got on:  The GM from my home club arranged a round, and I was impressed with our treatment by the staff of Baltusrol.  They treated us like kings - first rate the entire day!  

We played in early April and it had just snowed a couple weeks prior.  The course was still recovering from the long winter, so the grass was brownish and the greens were shaggy.  The clubhouse and course had a special feel to them though.  We joined up with a couple members for the last few holes and they were amazing.  We joined them for a drink (coke for me as a non-drinker) after the round, and had a great conversation.  It was obvious Baltusrol would be a great home club.  I'd love to get another crack at this one when it is running firm, fast, and is in peak summer shape.  

Bandon Dunes

Rankings

Golf Digest:  #37
Golfweek:  #8 Modern

Review to come

The Olympic Club - Lake

Rankings

Golf Digest:  #33
Golfweek:  #31 Classic

How I got on:  My college roommate, Ryan, arranged a round with a connection he had and we made a trip with two foursomes.  

Lucky for me, Southwest had a hard time getting my clubs from Southern to Northern California on a direct flight.  How's that happen?  I'm not genius, but that one is difficult to screw up.  We were slated to play the Lake course twice and the par 3 course.  I had to rent clubs for my first round and borrow shoes - a MAJOR disappointment for any avid golfer.  I don't think it affected my score thought.  The U.S. Amateur was being held the next week at Olympic, so the rough was being grown out.  And when I mean grown out, I mean 6-7" long - so long it was laying over like a bad hairdo.  If we missed the fairway, by only a few inches, we'd need to shuffle our feet around the area we thought the ball entered and only rarely found our balls.  Talk about difficult!!!  And my friend Ryan shot around par for both rounds - two of the best rounds I've seen.  

Olympic Lake has no water, and feels like a classic.  It bends with many doglegs that require working the ball due to the tall, tree-lined fairways.  I love courses that require you to hit a certain shot at specified times.  Olympic Lake makes you do that a number of times.  I remember many of the holes a decade later - something I can't say for a lot of nationally ranked tracks. 

The par 3 course sits overlooking the Pacific Ocean.  The holes are short, but have unique green complexes that are superbly maintained.  I'm fond of the ability to play a pitch and putt that feels like it is maintained with the same care as the championship courses.  

The Honors Course

Rankings

Golf Digest:  #31
Golfweek:  #23 Modern

How I got on:  I qualified for the U.S. Mid-Amateur championship in 2007.  

I played like garbage during the tournament, but the course was a privilege to play and I've been able to play it a few times since.  As a tribute to amateur golf, the club feels exactly like you'd expect for a Southern golf club.  It will always be one of my favorites due to the circumstances of my first rounds there.  It is a true championship course, and while not very old, the clubhouse, lockers, and cabins (where you can stay on-site) have a throwback feel to them.  

You'll likely miss the driveway to the course on your first visit.  It's in the middle of nowhere outside Chattanooga.  But once you make it down the first 100 yards of nondescript driveway, the trees open up into a perfect plot of land for a course.  

Most of the holes are perfectly memorable.  I do remember teeing off on the first during my opening round of the mid-am, and I'm shocked I made contact.  I think my full arm, no shoulder turn landed in a fairway bunker less than 200 yards off the tee.  But I didn't whiff!  

The greens are lightning quick and do not present many simple putts.  You need to think your way around the course and set yourself up for easier approaches.  And don't miss on the wrong side of the greens.  Most of the course winds through dense trees, with a few that open up a bit.  But the ones that do open up have thick rough or fescue to defend.  Maybe I just didn't have my game (every time I played there), but from the tips it has beaten me down.

I'd recommend a trip to Chattanooga if you can find a host to get on Honors.  Bring some extra balls - there's a lot of fescue, water, trees...I believe I found other trouble, but have blocked the rest out.  

Los Angeles CC

Rankings

Golf Digest:  #26
Golfweek:  #16 Classic

How I got on:  My friend from Big Canyon CC, Stewart, is also a member at LACC.  

Friars Head

Rankings

Golf Digest:  #23
Golfweek:  #3 Modern

How I got on:  An industry friend, Bob, found out I was a golfer and we took a detour from our property tour to play an "emergency round."  I like the way Bob thinks.  

Whistling Straits - Straits

Rankings

Golf Digest:  #22
Golfweek:  #6 Modern

Review to come

Pacific Dunes

Rankings

Golf Digest:  #18
Golfweek:  #2 Modern

See my Bandon Trails post for a more detailed description of this trip.  Pacific Dunes was the first track I played at Bandon, and I don't think I was really awake after my 3am arrival.  So I'm not sure I was paying very good attention.  Pacific is traditionally rated as the favorite of the four courses, but I didn't see much that made it better than the others except for overlooking the ocean on many holes.  I definitely need to play it again to see if I understand the excess hype on PD.  I'll keep the review short since the course was a bit of a blur, but all the courses at Bandon are special.  It's a perfect place to get away and do nothing but golf.  I loved the entire experience.